Very good, effective paddling with a serious paddle. She should have been stripped naked in the course of punishment to be followed by a lengthy period of naked corner time with hands on her head. Humiliation should go hand in hand with physical punishment.
Thats a realy hard paddling. I know the paddle with holes, they hurts more than the cane, the riding crop or nearly everything else. My mistress used it and I my ass was black and blue, later green and yellow for one week